In legal disputes where significant commercial interests are at stake, it is crucial that your lawyer has a thorough understanding of both the facts and the commercial context in which the dispute arises. Only when your lawyer truly understands the core of the matter can they present your case persuasively before a court or arbitral tribunal. Our exclusive focus on the agri-food sector over many years gives us a distinct advantage in this respect.
Successfully pursuing or defending legal proceedings requires strategic insight, patience, and, at the appropriate moments, decisiveness and assertiveness.
Your Interests Determine Our Strategy
Everything we do, and how we do it, is guided by your commercial objectives and interests. In some situations, this means that we coach and support you during negotiations while remaining in the background. This approach may be appropriate where no formal proceedings have yet been initiated and an amicable settlement remains achievable. In other cases, a more proactive approach is required. We may issue formal demands on your behalf, obtain pre-judgment attachments, secure evidence, or represent you in court proceedings, including urgent interim relief proceedings, where swift action is essential to protect your interests.
Every Matter Starts with a Legal and Commercial SWOT Analysis
Whatever strategy is most appropriate, we always begin by assessing the strengths and weaknesses of both our client’s position and that of the opposing party. This enables us to evaluate the opportunities and risks of litigation or arbitration. We also consider the broader commercial implications, such as the potential impact of legal proceedings on your business and the extent to which you depend on the commercial relationship concerned.
We are straightforward in our advice. If we believe you have a strong case, we will tell you. Equally, if we consider the prospects of success uncertain, for example because the available evidence is limited, we will discuss that openly as well. In many situations, the best outcome for a client is not necessarily winning a court case. Sometimes the real victory lies in avoiding unnecessary escalation and achieving a commercially acceptable settlement that reflects the realities of the situation.
Securing the Outcome You Are Entitled To
That said, legal proceedings, despite the risks, costs and uncertainties involved, are sometimes necessary. They can also be a highly effective means of creating leverage and breaking a deadlock. Litigation or arbitration may be required to compel a business partner to honour contractual commitments, stop conduct that is causing harm to your business, or compensate you for losses suffered.
After all, you are not required to accept unreasonable demands or contractual breaches by others. In fact, the mere willingness to pursue legal action and defend your interests can sometimes be enough to encourage a counterparty to adopt a more constructive position.
An Experienced Litigator with Deep Agri-Food Expertise
Whatever your objectives may be, we assist and guide you through every stage of the legal proceedings in which you become involved. Our in-depth knowledge of the agri-food sector, combined with extensive experience in commercial litigation and dispute resolution, gives us a significant advantage when identifying the arguments that are most likely to influence the outcome of your case. By combining legal expertise with a thorough understanding of the commercial realities of the agri-food industry, we maximise your prospects of success.
Examples of Our Litigation and Arbitration Experience
- We assisted one of the largest Dutch vegetable breeding companies in a dispute with a US grower operating throughout the Americas. The grower claimed to have obtained exclusive rights to cultivate and market a successful tomato variety developed by our client. We supported the breeder during negotiations, coordinated parallel legal proceedings in the Netherlands, and instructed US local counsel. The matter was ultimately settled, and the grower withdrew its claims.
- We represented a seed producer that had worked for decades with a globally active breeding company. The collaboration was terminated abruptly after a disease outbreak affected the crops. Together with our client, we developed a strategic response and initially sought a negotiated solution. When negotiations proved unsuccessful, we commenced and pursued multiple legal proceedings. Ultimately, the breeder abandoned its position, and the dispute was resolved through a highly favourable settlement for our client.
- We successfully represented a Bolivian peanut exporter accused of supplying peanuts contaminated with aflatoxin. The products had been delivered to an importer in Rotterdam, processed into peanut butter, and subsequently supplied to a retail chain in Sweden. We acted for the exporter in multiple NOFOTA arbitrations and proceedings before the District Court of Rotterdam. The importer’s claim was ultimately rejected in its entirety.
- We represented a Dutch seed technology start-up in a dispute with an adviser who, during the company's early development phase, asserted claims of such magnitude that the business itself would have been jeopardised if they had succeeded. We successfully defended the matter before both the District Court and the Court of Appeal, resulting in the complete dismissal of all claims.
- We assisted a Chilean blueberry exporter in legal proceedings against a Rotterdam-based importer who claimed entitlement to long-term supply arrangements while simultaneously failing to pay outstanding invoices with a value approaching EUR 500,000. We successfully represented the exporter in multiple proceedings before both the District Court and the Court of Appeal.
- We obtained a pre-judgment attachment on behalf of a Rotterdam fruit importer against a customer who refused to pay outstanding invoices. We subsequently conducted successful court proceedings, after which the debt was recovered in full, including the costs incurred by our client.
Key Takeaway
Why is industry expertise important in litigation and arbitration?
Successful dispute resolution requires more than legal knowledge alone. In complex agri-food disputes, a lawyer must understand both the legal issues and the commercial realities of the sector. By combining deep agri-food industry expertise with strategic litigation and arbitration experience, businesses can make informed decisions, manage risk effectively, strengthen their negotiating position, and maximise their prospects of achieving a commercially successful outcome.
