A pre-judgment attachment can have a significant impact on your business operations. What can you do if it happens to you?
Suddenly, you discover that your bank account has been frozen, your logistics provider is no longer permitted to release your goods, your customers are unable to pay outstanding invoices, and a bailiff appears at your premises. What happened? A business partner with whom you are in dispute has applied to the court, without prior notice to you, for permission to impose a pre-judgment attachment, and the court has granted that request. What can you do now?
Why a Pre-Judgment Attachment Often Comes as a Surprise
First of all, although a pre-judgment attachment can be highly disruptive, the fact that it comes as a surprise is entirely lawful.
When deciding whether to grant permission for a pre-judgment attachment, the court is generally not required to inform or hear the party against whom the attachment is sought. In other words, you will usually only become aware of the attachment once it has already been imposed.
A Pre-Judgment Attachment Can Remain in Place for Years
As a general rule, a pre-judgment attachment remains in place until a court judgment or arbitral award has become final and binding, meaning that no further appeals are possible.
It is not unusual for court proceedings to take eighteen months to more than two years. If your counterparty loses and files an appeal, it may take another one or two years before the outcome of the appeal becomes known. Even then, proceedings before the Dutch Supreme Court may still follow, potentially adding several more years to the process.
If you take no action, the attachment can remain in place throughout this entire period. The practical consequences for your business can be substantial.
Where a business has been financed with borrowed capital, such as a bank loan, financing agreements often contain provisions allowing the lender to terminate the facility if an attachment is not lifted within a specified period. Although lenders do not always exercise this right, it is certainly something that should be taken into account.
Offering Alternative Security
The quickest and most straightforward way to have a pre-judgment attachment lifted is often to offer alternative security. The court order authorising the attachment specifies the maximum amount for which the attachment may be imposed. If you offer a bank guarantee or another acceptable form of security for that amount, the party that obtained the attachment is generally required to accept that security and release the attachment.
Of course, obtaining a bank guarantee involves costs. In practice, however, those costs are often significantly lower than the costs and losses that may result from being unable to access your funds or dispose of your goods for an extended period.
Can You Seek the Release of an Attachment Through Summary Proceedings?
If the party that obtained the attachment refuses to release it in exchange for adequate alternative security, this may provide strong grounds for seeking its release through summary proceedings.
The law also recognises other grounds on which a court may order an attachment to be lifted. These include:
- Where it is apparent, on a preliminary assessment, that the underlying claim lacks merit, for example because the wrong legal entity has been sued or because the claim is time-barred.
- Where the request for the attachment was based on demonstrably incorrect factual information.
Obtaining a Pre-Judgment Attachment Is Relatively Easy. Having It Lifted Is Not
In practice, obtaining permission to impose a pre-judgment attachment is often relatively straightforward. Successfully securing the release of an attachment through summary proceedings is generally much more difficult.
If an application to lift the attachment is unsuccessful, there may be little alternative but to continue defending the underlying proceedings and await a favourable outcome in the main dispute.
Until then, the attachment will usually remain in place, together with any consequences it may have for your business operations.
