What happens if you win or lose a legal dispute? Which costs can you recover, and which costs might you be required to pay? Below, we outline the main principles.
In the Netherlands, it is customary for the court to order the unsuccessful party to pay the legal costs of the successful party. In the vast majority of cases, however, such a costs order covers only a portion of the actual costs incurred by the winning party.
As a result, if you win, you will usually recover only part of your legal costs. Conversely, if you lose, you will generally not be required to pay all of your opponent's actual legal costs.
Court Fees and Bailiff's Costs
In practice, a costs order almost always requires the unsuccessful party to reimburse the court fees and any bailiff's costs incurred by the successful party.
In addition, any witness expenses and expert fees awarded by the court must generally be reimbursed, provided that such costs were actually incurred by the successful party.
Limited Recovery of Legal Fees
Dutch courts generally do not award reimbursement of the actual legal fees incurred by the winning party. Instead, the Dutch system applies a fixed-scale compensation for legal fees. Points are assigned to specific procedural steps, and each point is associated with a predetermined amount. The resulting figure represents the amount that the unsuccessful party must contribute towards the winning party's legal fees.
This is an important consideration when deciding whether to litigate. Even if you succeed, you will usually recover only a limited portion of your actual legal costs. The same principle works in reverse. If you lose, you will generally not be required to reimburse the actual legal fees incurred by the opposing party.
Full Cost Recovery
Only in exceptional circumstances will a Dutch court order full recovery of legal costs. A full costs order requires the unsuccessful party not only to reimburse the standard litigation costs, but also to pay the actual legal fees incurred by the other party.
The first exception applies in cases involving the enforcement of intellectual property rights, such as copyright, patents, trademarks, or plant breeders' rights. In such cases, the successful party may recover legal fees that are considered reasonable and proportionate. In principle, this means the actual legal costs incurred, subject to limitations that depend on the complexity of the case.
The second exception concerns abuse of process. This may arise where a party has knowingly attempted to mislead the court by presenting information it knew to be false, or where a party advances arguments that are clearly indefensible and thereby leaves the opposing party with no realistic alternative but to engage in litigation. Merely losing a case is emphatically not sufficient grounds for a full costs order.
After the Proceedings Have Ended
If you have successfully obtained a costs order, we must first give the opposing party the opportunity to comply voluntarily.
If payment is not made within two weeks, we may, after consulting with you, instruct a bailiff to formally serve the judgment. If payment is still not forthcoming after service of the judgment, the bailiff can take enforcement measures against the unsuccessful party to recover the costs awarded by the court. In principle, the unsuccessful party will also be liable for the additional enforcement costs incurred. However, if there are no recoverable assets, for example because the debtor has been declared bankrupt or simply lacks sufficient funds, there may be nothing to recover and the costs order may ultimately remain unpaid.
